Review of Tournament Poker and the Art of War
- Title:
- Tournament Poker and the Art of War
- Author:
- David Apostolico
- Publisher:
- Lyle Stuart
- Date:
- 2005
- ISBN:
- 0-8184-0647-X
- Pages:
- 151
- Price:
- $12.95
March 2, 2005
About 2500 years ago, The Art of War was written as a treatise
on military strategy. In recent years the book has come into favor among
many in the business world as a general guide to contests of all sorts.
In Tournament Poker and the Art of War, David Apostolico
applies this classic text to playing in no-limit Texas hold'em poker
tournaments.
Sun Tzu's The Art of War was not written as a nuts-and-bolts
text book on military operations. By stating its lessons in very general
terms, it attempts not to teach specifics but to cultivate a
mind set in its audience. As with most classic works that have
remained popular centuries after they were written, this book's general
approach allows its principles to be adapted to situations far different
than those with which the original author was familiar. It's not much
of a reach to think that many of the principles in The Art of
War could be adapted to poker. The value of such an exercise
is going to depend on how well the author performs the adaptation.
Apostolico's book is organized into the same thirteen chapters as the
Sun Tzu book, apparently using the Giles translation. For those who
may wish to read the unabridged text in conjunction with Tournament
Poker and the Art of War, the translation Apostolico uses is
published by Dover Publications and is available online at several web
sites free of charge. This is a well known translation, and
while it may be slightly out of favor these days among scholars
and purists, it is certainly adequate for these purposes.
In this work, Apostolico selects a short quote, typically only a sentence
or two, and then makes some remarks adapting this quote to no-limit
tournament poker. Sometimes the commentary consists of a single line,
sometimes it runs for a couple of paragraphs. As one might expect,
these comments run the gamut from insightful to reasonable to uninteresting
to inappropriate. It is my opinion, though, that too many of Apostolico's
remarks tend toward the lower end of the quality scale.
One of the benefits of a book like The Art of War is the
general applicability of its statements. However, in applying this
material to tournament poker, Apostolico needs to cast aside the
timelessness of the original material and come up with specifics. I
believe he fails to do so. Poker is all about both caution and
aggression. Without specifics these are irreconcilable goals. Winning
at poker is all about knowing the right situations in which to be
cautious and when to be aggressive. Tournament Poker and the
Art of War doesn't provide enough information for the reader
to navigate this dichotomy. Consequently, I don't believe it succeeds
as a book.
Poker players who are fans of The Art of War and are looking
for affirmations that might inspire deeper introspection might be
entertained by Tournament Poker and the Art of War. I
believe that most readers looking for an application of timeless wisdom
toward the game of poker will ultimately be disappointed by this book.
Capsule:
David Apostolico has taken the Sun Tzu classic, The Art of War
and applied its general message to no-limit poker tournaments. While
a few of his interpretations are interesting or even insightful, it is my
opinion that too few of them make the grade to make this book worthwhile
to most poker players.
|