Review of The Best Hand I Ever Played

Title:

The Best Hand I Ever Played

Author:

Steve Rosenbloom

Publisher:

ESPN Books

Date:

2005

ISBN:

1-933060-03-4

Pages:

186

Price:

$15.95

Reviewed by Nick Christenson, npc@lvrevealed.com

November 14, 2005

Many, perhaps most, poker players remember a hand they played where everything just clicked, where out of the blue some insight struck that led to a good raise, call, or fold that that previously wasn't on the table. Sometimes a flash of insight like this will be a catalyst that takes a player's game to a whole new level. In The Best Hand I Ever Played, Steve Rosenbloom asks 52 famous poker players to recount the most memorable hand they ever played. This book chronicles their answers and provides analysis about some truly remarkable hands.

The Best Hand I Ever Played is comprised of 52 vignettes, each of which includes some background on the player in question, their recollection of their most memorable hand, and an analysis of the hand (called "The Rake" for some reason) by author Rosenbloom. These stories are organized alphabetically by their subject. Ostensibly, the theme of the book is "best" hands, hands where the hero of the story played especially well or played a hand where they learned something profound. Not all the players interviewed followed Rosenbloom guidelines, however. Many of the hands fall into the category of "most memorable" rather than "best played".

Some of the hands I found especially interesting. The hand T.J. Cloutier recounts wins my award for most improbable, although I don't think there's a poker lesson there. The hand Dewey Tomko recounts is the most entertaining one, and shows that sometimes there's more to be won and lost than just the money in the pot. From a strategic standpoint, my favorite hand story is the one told by Martin De Knijff. I believe his hand selection shows more depth than any other in this book.

The Best Hand I Played is a book geared more toward entertainment than strategy. Insight can be found in some of the hands discussed in this book, but there's less than the strategic-minded poker player would like. One of the reasons for this is that I was not at all impressed with Rosenbloom's analysis of these situations. For many of the hands, he is forced to reach to find some insight where there is little to work with, and this isn't his fault. However, even when a hand is discussed with interesting implications, I found his analysis to be rather shallow and uninteresting, and in at least a couple of cases I think he significantly misinterprets what the player he interviews is saying.

Rosenbloom's book is a quick read. Each story is weighs in at about two or three pages, and the way the book is formatted makes for a fair bit of "dead air" throughout. Nonetheless, the book is entertaining enough to probably make it worthwhile to poker fans. An industrious reader will find some nuggets of strategic interest, but the book really isn't all that deep, so I give it a mild recommendation for those looking for entertainment and the completist looking for something light.

Capsule:

Steve Rosenbloom interviewed 52 of the most famous poker players about The Best Hand They Ever Played. The result is light and entertaining, but rarely strategically interesting. The book is short and sometimes provides a little insight, so those looking for something fun or those who read many poker books will probably be satisfied with this one, but it's not a must-read.